why is "Hugo et toi" vous and not ils?
It's the same in English. Would you say:
(a) Hugo and you, you're coming with me! -- Hugo et toi, vous m'accompagnez! (correct)(b) Hugo and you, they are coming with me! -- Hugo et toi, ils m'accompagnent! (wrong)
Using second person plural, you are addressing a group of people. Third person plural would mean that you are talking about a group of people with someone separate from the group:
(c) Hugo et Marie, ils m'accompagnent. Toi, tu restes ici. -- Hugo and Marie, they are coming with me. You stay here. (correct)
Hugo represents a grammatical third-person singular.
Toi represents a grammatical second-person singular.
So together they need to be expressed as "vous" - (all of you). They cannot be represented by "Ils" because this is a group of grammatical third-person plural.
Hope this helps.
Sign in to submit your answer
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Test your French to the CEFR standard