how come it's incorrect to write "je n'ai pas une soeur" as opposed to "de soeur"?
une vs de soeur
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
une vs de soeur
The question "how come" is always tempting to ask and often difficult to answer, simply because languages aren't math and don't always follow the rules of logic.
In this case, it may help that English, too, doesn't use the definite article after negations. If someone asks you, "Do you have a sister?" you answer with, "No, I don't have a sister," and not "No I don't have one sister". In French it is similar.

I don't know that it's incorrect. I suspect you can say both. But this a situation of emphasising "one" or "any".
(Also, in French as in English, often one construction just sounds better than another.)
une vs de soeur
how come it's incorrect to write "je n'ai pas une soeur" as opposed to "de soeur"?
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level