Ambiguity in posseessive pronoun?

PeterC1Kwiziq community member

Ambiguity in posseessive pronoun?

"He reminds Maria of her ex." is translated as 
"Il rappelle son ex à Maria." 
What is the translation of  "He reminds Maria of his ex."?In other words, how do we know whether the possessive pronoun refers to the subject or the indirect object?
Asked 3 months ago
MaartenC1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor Correct answer

Peter,  

In this particular French sentence and expression '…..rappelle son ex à …’ neither the gender of the 'owner', nor of the 'possession - the 'ex' - can be unambiguously identified without further context, as the noun 'ex' is invariable.

To clarify, this is a possessive adjective - in this case 'son' - which is doubly ambiguous here because it precedes an invariable noun that starts with a vowel -  ‘ex’.

The possessive adjectives themselves never identify the gender(s) of the ‘owner', although in many constructs and contexts it will be clear. 

The answer to knowing the meaning is context. The context would need to be known or provided in a longer description of the situation - this expression cannot provide that information in this simple format. If not, clarifying questions could/would be asked in a conversation. 

Mon, ma, mes; ton, ta, tes; son, sa, ses = my; your; his / her in French (French possessive adjectives)

 https://www.larousse.fr/dictionnaires/francais/ex/31911

Peter asked:View original

Ambiguity in posseessive pronoun?

"He reminds Maria of her ex." is translated as 
"Il rappelle son ex à Maria." 
What is the translation of  "He reminds Maria of his ex."?In other words, how do we know whether the possessive pronoun refers to the subject or the indirect object?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
Getting that for you now...