I don’t understand why the pronoun “le” is added to sentences where it doesn’t seem necessary.

Judy R.B2Kwiziq community member

I don’t understand why the pronoun “le” is added to sentences where it doesn’t seem necessary.

Asked 2 weeks ago
CécileNative French expert teacher in KwiziqCorrect answer

Judy,

Without any context it is hard to make any comments.

just to add to what Chris and Maarten have said -

Je l'ai dit I said it 

Je lui ai dit I told him

Je le lui ai dit = I told him ( it/so)

These are object pronouns some direct and indirect.

This is too large a subject to discuss on this forum.

Jim J.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

https://www.lawlessfrench.com/grammar/definite-article/

Judy R.B2Kwiziq community member

Another example not covered in the lesson on definite articles:” Oui, je l’ai dit” meaning “Yes, I told him”. It doesn’t mean Yes I told him it, so why is the “le” or “l’ needed?

Chris W.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

Maybe my answer to your similar question above sheds some light on this?

When learnining French, I often banged my head against the wall when asking "why is that..." questions. Often the answer is simply: because that's the French way.

That said, in sentences of the type you refer to, a previously mentioned idea is implied. "I told him." is only meaningful if the speaker knows what he told him. In English, you can leave that implication hanging in mid air and all's good. Not so in French. Here you need to tie that implication to the pronoun le.

The problem only arises when, in your head, you're translating the French (with the le) to English, where it sounds superflous. My advice is just to stop translating.

Maarten K.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

Judy, 

effectively ' je l'ai dit ' does mean " I told him it (that/something) " as Chris highlights, but that is simply not what we would usually say in English. 

It is important to remember that  " translation ",  is not the same as word for word ' rewriting '.  

You might also find the attached link useful : 

https://www.lawlessfrench.com/grammar/neuter-object-pronoun/

I don’t understand why the pronoun “le” is added to sentences where it doesn’t seem necessary.

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
Clever stuff happening!