Il ya a, c'est and ce sont
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
Paul B.Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor
Il ya a, c'est and ce sont
Hello, I am having difficulty when to use Il ya a, c'est and ce sont.
Is there a resource on Kwiziq that can teach me the right way to use these alternatives?
This question relates to:French lesson "Il y a = There is/There are in French"
Asked 6 years ago
Ok, let's take "il y a" first. It means simply "there is/are" in the sense of that it exists or is present. For example: "Il y a de grandes montagnes en Autriche" -- "There are big mountains in Austria."
"C'est/ce sont" means "it is/they are". In this context "ce" is immutable and will never be "ces". "Ces" is a demonstrative pronoun and belongs to the family "ces, celles, ceux". It always needs a noun and is matched in number and gender to it.
Ce ne sont que des enfants -- They are only children.
Ces enfants se comportent bien. -- These children behave well.
Il y a des pommes fraîches? -- Are there fresh apples?
Ce sont des pommes fraîches. -- These are fresh apples.
Ces pommes sont fraîches. -- These apples are fresh.
Does this make it any clearer?
-- Chris (not a native speaker).
"C'est/ce sont" means "it is/they are". In this context "ce" is immutable and will never be "ces". "Ces" is a demonstrative pronoun and belongs to the family "ces, celles, ceux". It always needs a noun and is matched in number and gender to it.
Ce ne sont que des enfants -- They are only children.
Ces enfants se comportent bien. -- These children behave well.
Il y a des pommes fraîches? -- Are there fresh apples?
Ce sont des pommes fraîches. -- These are fresh apples.
Ces pommes sont fraîches. -- These apples are fresh.
Does this make it any clearer?
-- Chris (not a native speaker).
Paul B.Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor
Thanks for your help Chris.
Rewriting your answer without the discussion of "ces" I get:
"il y a" ... means simply "there is/are" in the sense of that it exists or is present.
For example: "Il y a de grandes montagnes en Autriche" -- "There are big mountains in Austria."
"C'est/ce sont" means "it is/they are"...(and these are)....
Ce ne sont que des enfants -- They are only children.
Il y a des pommes fraîches? -- Are there fresh apples?
Ce sont des pommes fraîches. -- These are fresh apples.
So, if I understand correctly:
Ce sont des enfants - These/They are children
Il y a des enfants - There are children.
Chris W. Kwiziq Q&A super contributor
Yes, correct. Only "They are children" woukd be "Ils sont des enfants." Otherwise you surmise correctly.
-- Chris.
CécileNative French expert teacher in Kwiziq
Just a correction to Chris' excellent answer you cannot say:
"Ils sont des enfants" always "Ce sont des enfants".
In the same way as,
"C'est Marie " and not "Elle est Marie" or
"C'est mon frère" and not "Il est mon frère"
Hope this helps!
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Ask a question
Find your French level for FREE
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level