Which past tense?

Scott O.C1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

Which past tense?

I was asked to fill in the blank for the sentence, "After he said that, he left," where the conjugation of dire was missing. I had been asked so much lately about passé simple that I used simply dit, when a dit was expected. I was marked wrong for that.

But isn't it also correct, although unexpected? Or is it just that a native speaker would never do that for such a simple sentence, so it should be discouraged?

Asked 3 weeks ago
CécileKwiziq Native French TeacherCorrect answer

Bonjour Scott,

If I have understood your question correctly, you wanted to use the passé simple of dire, but it is the wrong tense here; you would need the passé antérieur as the action precedes 'il partit', which would be in the passé simple.

Après qu'il eut dit ça, il partit

However, you are complicating things, and it is not needed here; it wouldn't have been accepted anyway.

But very clever of you to suggest a more literary sentence.

If you dont know this tense, here is a brief description -

Le Passé Antérieur (Indicatif)

Hope this helps!

 

Scott O. asked:

Which past tense?

I was asked to fill in the blank for the sentence, "After he said that, he left," where the conjugation of dire was missing. I had been asked so much lately about passé simple that I used simply dit, when a dit was expected. I was marked wrong for that.

But isn't it also correct, although unexpected? Or is it just that a native speaker would never do that for such a simple sentence, so it should be discouraged?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

And get your personalised Study Plan to improve it

Find your French level
Getting that for you now...