Combien coûte ce livre ?

Thanh P.A1Kwiziq community member

Combien coûte ce livre ?

Hello , to my understanding , there are 2 types of question ,formal and informal . But what type is this that the question "Combien coûte ce livre ?" belongs to ?, Because it's not follow the formulas for formal type ( Est-ce que or inversion ) . And it's not also follow the formula itonation for informal type (question word + statement itonation) like Combien ce livre coûte ?. Why combien is an adverb but can be followed by a verb (coûte).  So it confuses me here  . Can you explain for me please ?

Asked 6 days ago
Maarten K.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor Correct answer

Thanh, 

it is an ‘ inverted question ‘, - the same structure as - ‘ combien coûte-t-il ? ‘, - question word - verb - subject. However, the article-noun ‘ ce livre ‘ is used for the subject, not a pronoun. 

For example, the context could be that the book is being identified for the first time, or is one of a few under consideration and to avoid ambiguity/confusion the specific demonstrative ‘ ce livre ‘ is used, as a pronoun would not be appropriate.

From the lesson description 

“ You use the question word at the beginning of the sentence, followed by the inverted verb and then the subject. This is a more elegant and more formal way to ask questions in French. “ 

Don’t be confused by the bold ‘ inverted verb ‘ - the inversion is the reversal from the usual ‘ subject- verb ‘ order of a statement to the inverted  ‘ verb - subject ‘ structure of a question. 

The other difference is that a trait d’union is used between the verb and a subject pronoun ( plus or minus a euphonic ‘ t ‘ as needed, as in this example ), but not between verb and subject nouns. 

 Inverted questions in the present tense (Le Présent) in French - il/elle/on forms

 Inverted questions in the present tense (Le Présent) in French - regular forms (except il/elle/on forms)

Perhaps a similar inverted example with a noun could be added in relevant section of the lesson to clarify. 

Thanh P.A1Kwiziq community member

Thank you Maaten K . Your explaination is very clear and easy to understand . So if i want to say "Your mother speaks France ?" with inverted question i can just write "Parle sa mère le francais ?"

CécileKwiziq team member

Hi Thanh,

Just to add to Maarten's very detailed explanation and to concentrate on your examples 

informal : Ce livre coûte combien ?

formal : Combien coûte ce livre ?

             Combien ce livre coûte-t-il ?

informal : Est-ce-que ta mère parle français? 

               Ta mère parle français ? ( with raised intonation                    at the end)

formal : Ta mère parle-t-elle français ?

Hope this helps!

Thanh P.A1Kwiziq community member

Thank you cecile , i just have a wonder 

In formal case with inversion we can write "Combien coûte ce livre ?" but can we write "Parle ta mère le francais ?"  ? If not , then why ? i think "ce livre" and "ta mère" are the same , they not subject pronouns , i think they both are subject nouns. Please help me , I'm very much appreciate !

Combien coûte ce livre ?

Hello , to my understanding , there are 2 types of question ,formal and informal . But what type is this that the question "Combien coûte ce livre ?" belongs to ?, Because it's not follow the formulas for formal type ( Est-ce que or inversion ) . And it's not also follow the formula itonation for informal type (question word + statement itonation) like Combien ce livre coûte ?. Why combien is an adverb but can be followed by a verb (coûte).  So it confuses me here  . Can you explain for me please ?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
Let me take a look at that...