Combien coûte ce livre ?

Thanh P.A1Kwiziq community member

Combien coûte ce livre ?

Hello , to my understanding , there are 2 types of question ,formal and informal . But what type is this that the question "Combien coûte ce livre ?" belongs to ?, Because it's not follow the formulas for formal type ( Est-ce que or inversion ) . And it's not also follow the formula itonation for informal type (question word + statement itonation) like Combien ce livre coûte ?. Why combien is an adverb but can be followed by a verb (coûte).  So it confuses me here  . Can you explain for me please ?

Asked 1 month ago
Maarten K.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor Correct answer

Thanh, 

it is an ‘ inverted question ‘, - the same structure as - ‘ combien coûte-t-il ? ‘, - question word - verb - subject. However, the article-noun ‘ ce livre ‘ is used for the subject, not a pronoun. 

For example, the context could be that the book is being identified for the first time, or is one of a few under consideration and to avoid ambiguity/confusion the specific demonstrative ‘ ce livre ‘ is used, as a pronoun would not be appropriate.

From the lesson description 

“ You use the question word at the beginning of the sentence, followed by the inverted verb and then the subject. This is a more elegant and more formal way to ask questions in French. “ 

Don’t be confused by the bold ‘ inverted verb ‘ - the inversion is the reversal from the usual ‘ subject- verb ‘ order of a statement to the inverted  ‘ verb - subject ‘ structure of a question. 

The other difference is that a trait d’union is used between the verb and a subject pronoun ( plus or minus a euphonic ‘ t ‘ as needed, as in this example ), but not between verb and subject nouns. 

 Inverted questions in the present tense (Le Présent) in French - il/elle/on forms

 Inverted questions in the present tense (Le Présent) in French - regular forms (except il/elle/on forms)

Perhaps a similar inverted example with a noun could be added in relevant section of the lesson to clarify. 

Thanh P.A1Kwiziq community member

Thank you Maaten K . Your explaination is very clear and easy to understand . So if i want to say "Your mother speaks France ?" with inverted question i can just write "Parle sa mère le francais ?"

CécileNative French expert teacher in Kwiziq

Hi Thanh,

Just to add to Maarten's very detailed explanation and to concentrate on your examples 

informal : Ce livre coûte combien ?

formal : Combien coûte ce livre ?

             Combien ce livre coûte-t-il ?

informal : Est-ce-que ta mère parle français? 

               Ta mère parle français ? ( with raised intonation                    at the end)

formal : Ta mère parle-t-elle français ?

Hope this helps!

Thanh P.A1Kwiziq community member

Thank you cecile , i just have a wonder 

In formal case with inversion we can write "Combien coûte ce livre ?" but can we write "Parle ta mère le francais ?"  ? If not , then why ? i think "ce livre" and "ta mère" are the same , they not subject pronouns , i think they both are subject nouns. Please help me , I'm very much appreciate !

Thanh P. asked:

Combien coûte ce livre ?

Hello , to my understanding , there are 2 types of question ,formal and informal . But what type is this that the question "Combien coûte ce livre ?" belongs to ?, Because it's not follow the formulas for formal type ( Est-ce que or inversion ) . And it's not also follow the formula itonation for informal type (question word + statement itonation) like Combien ce livre coûte ?. Why combien is an adverb but can be followed by a verb (coûte).  So it confuses me here  . Can you explain for me please ?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
I'll be right with you...