Confondus - context in the sentence "Chaque fois qu'il franchissait le seuil d'une classe, élèves et professeurs confondus se taisaient à l'unisson"

Jim L.C1KwizIQ Q&A regular contributor

Confondus - context in the sentence "Chaque fois qu'il franchissait le seuil d'une classe, élèves et professeurs confondus se taisaient à l'unisson"

This was a very enjoyable (and challenging) dictée (but then I do have a fetish for the subjunctive for some reason!)

A vocabulary question, however. I can't quite see what function the word "confondus" is playing in the sentence "Chaque fois qu'il franchissait le seuil d'une classe, élèves et professeurs confondus se taisaient à l'unisson." Clearly the sense of this is something like "Whenever he crossed the threshold of a classroom, pupils and teachers alike fell silent together", but how does "confondu" function in this? I suppose I'm asking how it literally translates, so I can make sense of its idiomatic use... 

Asked 2 weeks ago
CélineKwizIQ Native French TeacherCorrect answer

Bonjour Jim,

Thank you for your kind comment about this exercise! I definitely had fun writing it ;-)

Here, "confondus" is a past participle used as an adjective and is from the verb "confondre" ( = to confuse / to foil / to baffle / to combine / to merge). Its literal meaning is here "pupils and teachers merged together". So, as you stated earlier, it means "pupils and teachers alike".

I hope this is helpful.

Bonne journée !

CélineKwizIQ Native French TeacherCorrect answer

Bonjour N. Hilary,

You are right that "confondu" can mean "overcome/speechless". But it doesn't fit in a sentence in the same way:

Confondu de honte, il avait bassé la tête. = Overwhelmed with shame, he (had) bent his head.

Je suis confondu de gratitude ! = I am overwhelmed with grateful !

Je suis confondu ! = I am speechless!

The Collins dictionary doesn't just mention "confounded" as a translation for "confondu". It also mentions the following which is in line with what I explained to Jim:

 

toutes catégories confondues = taking all categories together

This correlates with my explanation above. The expression "[...] et [...] confondu(e/s/es)" is a fixed idiomatic construction meaning "[...] and [...] together / combined / alike". The image behind it is exactly that "merge" sense: the two groups blend into one undifferentiated mass. Therefore, a good translation of "élèves et professeurs confondus" would be "students and teachers alike" as Jim's suggested.

I hope this is helpful.

Bonne journée !

Jim L.C1KwizIQ Q&A regular contributor

Très aidant - merci Céline !

N. Hilary (Shamrockhill) W.C1KwizIQ Q&A super contributor

Hi Jim, I looked up "confondu" in Collins dictionary and it defines it as (=stupefait) "speechless, overcome". 

The verb "confondre" is defined as: "to mix up, to confuse".

The reflexive verb, "se confondre" is defined as "to merge".

So, I took this to mean "students and teachers overcome, fell silent together". 

Maybe Celine can shed some more light on this particular use of "confondu".

Merci et Bonne Continuation

Jim L. asked:

Confondus - context in the sentence "Chaque fois qu'il franchissait le seuil d'une classe, élèves et professeurs confondus se taisaient à l'unisson"

This was a very enjoyable (and challenging) dictée (but then I do have a fetish for the subjunctive for some reason!)

A vocabulary question, however. I can't quite see what function the word "confondus" is playing in the sentence "Chaque fois qu'il franchissait le seuil d'une classe, élèves et professeurs confondus se taisaient à l'unisson." Clearly the sense of this is something like "Whenever he crossed the threshold of a classroom, pupils and teachers alike fell silent together", but how does "confondu" function in this? I suppose I'm asking how it literally translates, so I can make sense of its idiomatic use... 

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

And get your personalised Study Plan to improve it

Find your French level
Thinking...