Elle fait de la danse ?

Blair C.A2Kwiziq community member

Elle fait de la danse ?

this does not seem right that in the lesson it is " she takes dance lessons".. i think it should be she dances.. and if you wanted to say someone is taking dance lessons it woudl be " Elle prend des cours de danse" 

Asked 3 weeks ago
Maarten K.C1Kwiziq Q&A super contributorCorrect answer

Blair,

 I think you may be trying to translate the words directly. This doesn’t always work !

Your alternative is not grammatically wrong but is redundant in context in most cases in everyday French conversation, and colloquially it would generally also be ‘ suivre un cours ‘, with ‘ prendre un cours ‘ somewhat of an anglicisme. 

‘ Suivre un cours de danse ‘ could be used when it was felt necessary to emphasise that ‘regular dancing’ was, or specifically included taking/having lessons, or when talking about taking courses more generally. 

However, the expression ‘ faire de la danse ‘ has a colloquial meaning in usual metropolitan  French usage - as is covered correctly in the lesson : 

“. ATTENTION:

When using "faire de la danse" or "faire de la natation" (FOR EXAMPLE) rather than simply "danser" or "nager", you refer more to an organised, repeated activity - I take dance lessons / I go swimming [as a regular activity, e.g. attending class or lessons] - than just a 'one-off' activity you're in the middle of doing such as I'm dancing / I'm swimming. “ 

 

Also have a look at a previous response by Cécile to a similar question/comment.

 

 https://progress.lawlessfrench.com/questions/view/couldn-t-elle-fait-de-la-danse-mean-she-s-a-professional-dancer

Blair C. asked:

Elle fait de la danse ?

this does not seem right that in the lesson it is " she takes dance lessons".. i think it should be she dances.. and if you wanted to say someone is taking dance lessons it woudl be " Elle prend des cours de danse" 

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

And get your personalised Study Plan to improve it

Find your French level
Let me take a look at that...