Subject agreement

Anita P.C1KwizIQ Q&A regular contributor

Subject agreement

In the sentence “Depuis qu’elle s’est fait mal avec le couteau l’année dernière” , why is it not “faite” as the subject is elle, or is it because it’s le couteau that hurt her and not a feminine object noun ?

Asked 6 years ago
Cécile J.A1KwizIQ Q&A super contributorCorrect answer

Hi Anita,

No, it is correct... 'faire'  behaves differently and becomes invariable in certain cases like this one - se faire mal = to get hurt 

You will say -

Elle s'est fait mal au genou = She hurt her knee

or 

Elles se sont fait mal en courant = They hurt themselves running

It is the same if 'se faire' is followed by another verb in the infinitive, the past participle of 'faire' will be invariable -

Elles se sont fait construire une maison à la campagne = They had a house built in the countryside

Breaks all the rules but true!

However, in the expression 'se faire à quelque chose' which means to get used to something the past participle will agree in the normal way -

Elle s'est faite à cette idée de déménagement = She has got used to this idea of moving

Hope this helps!

Brian E.C1KwizIQ Q&A regular contributor

I found your response on “faire/fait” very informative! Thanks Cécile. 

Anita P. asked:

Subject agreement

In the sentence “Depuis qu’elle s’est fait mal avec le couteau l’année dernière” , why is it not “faite” as the subject is elle, or is it because it’s le couteau that hurt her and not a feminine object noun ?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

And get your personalised Study Plan to improve it

Find your French level
Thinking...