In a recent test question: "In 1515, Francis I won the battle of Marignano." the correct answer was "a gagné" and not "gagne". Why does the "Historical Present" not apply in this case ?https://progress.lawlessfrench.com/questions/view/using-the-present-tense-like-the-past
Bonjour David,
This is best to be reported via the "Report issue" button on your Correction board as it will link the full test question to your query.
It is possible to use Le Présent historique when reporting a historical past event such as a famous battle, for example where the narrator wishes "to bring the event to life". However, it is also very common to use Le Passé Composé when simply relating the event as a past event. It will depend on the effect the narrator or the person talking wishes to express.
-> The action is seen as a completed one time event
-> the event is brought to life with the use of Le Présent historique
Also, the test question you mentioned above has a very specific hint: "Use "gagner" in the right past tense" so as to avoid this particular ambiguity. It is also linked to the following lesson Using the compound tense (Le Passé Composé) on its own or with the imperfect tense (L'Imparfait).
I hope this is helpful.
Bonne journée !
In a recent test question: "In 1515, Francis I won the battle of Marignano." the correct answer was "a gagné" and not "gagne". Why does the "Historical Present" not apply in this case ?https://progress.lawlessfrench.com/questions/view/using-the-present-tense-like-the-past
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Test your French to the CEFR standard
Find your French level